The Varsity Hall of Fame (formerly, the Pirate Club Hall of Fame) is composed of former athletes, athletic directors, managers, athletic trainers, team physicians, and all others who have distinguished themselves through Athletic Achievement and/or Dedication to the Varsity Sports program at Southeast Catholic, Bishop Neumann, St. John Neumann, St. Maria Goretti or Ss. John Neumann and Maria Goretti High School. The Millay Club is proud to honor for the first time in 2013, those contributions and achievements by the St. Maria Goretti student-athletes, coaches and administrators.

*Posthumous award