*Posthumous award
1967 - 1979
| Award Recipient | Year Awarded | Award Recipient | Year Awarded | |||
| William D. Valente '42 | 1967 | William J. Stewart '52 | 1973 | |||
| Henry M. "Hank" Clinton '44 | 1969 | Dennis J. "Bud" McNichol '38 | 1976 | |||
| Msgr. Francis J. Statkus, J.C.D. '38 | 1971 | Rev. Anthony W. Polini, O. Praem. '42 | 1977 | |||
| Frank J. Baldassarre '49 | 1972 | James Kearney '50 | 1979 | |||
| Frank A. Perri '49 | 1972 |
1980 - 1989
| Award Recipient | Year Awarded | Award Recipient | Year Awarded | |||
| Leonard L. Foti '41 | 1980 | John Finnegan '47 | 1985 | |||
| Michael Chitwood '61 | 1981 | Daniel J. Parrillo '67 | 1986 | |||
| Joseph E. O'Brien '44 | 1982 | Edward McNichol '39 | 1987 | |||
| John W. "Jake" Jordan '42 | 1983 | Leonard D. DeMasi '67 | 1988 | |||
| Ralph F. Desiderio '56 | 1984 | George Parker '50 | 1989 | |||
| John J. McLaughlin '51 | 1984 |
1990 - 1999
| Award Recipient | Year Awarded | Award Recipient | Year Awarded | |||
| John T. Riordan '63 | 1990 | John F. Malone '42 | 1995 | |||
| Richard J. Kearney '40 | 1991 | Phelim F. "Gabber" Dean, Jr. '45 | 1996 | |||
| Richard A. Tate '48 | 1992 | John J. Ardizzi '47 | 1997 | |||
| Paul J. Perrillo '75 | 1993 | Thomas F. Mellett '60 | 1998 | |||
| Rev. Mr. John C. Orlando '48 | 1994 | John Francesco '60 | 1999 |
2000 - 2009
| Award Recipient | Year Awarded | Award Recipient | Year Awarded | |||
| Edward J. Heffernan '52 | 2000 | Dr. Louis A. Papa '61 | 2006 | |||
| Dominic R. Lettieri '50 | 2001 | Anthony J. DeCarlo '58 | 2007 | |||
| William J. Kelly '53 | 2002 | Francis T. Foti '44 | 2008 | |||
| Edward J. McBride '55 | 2004 | Louis P. DeAngelo, Ed.D '76 | 2009 | |||
| Paul J. Phillips '41 | 2005 |
2010 - 2019
| Award Recipient | Year Awarded | Award Recipient | Year Awarded | |||
| Joseph F. Rufffenach '48 | 2010 | Denise Capotrio '73 | 2016 | |||
| Francis W. Rafferty '56 | 2011 | Diana Capotrio Stankiewicz '73 | 2016 | |||
| Father Douglas McKay '69 | 2012 | * | John McKenna '52 | 2017 | ||
| Patrick J. Graven, Jr. '90 | 2013 | Sister M. Rita Marotta, IHM '64 | 2018 | |||
| Lucille Cangelosi Hillerman '67 | 2014 | Hugh J. Quigley '96 | 2019 | |||
| Rev. Domenic A. Rossi, O. Praem. '66 | 2015 |